| Name | Term of Service |
| Louis Timothée (d. 1738) | November 14, 1732 – December 10, 1733 |
| Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790) | December 10, 1733 – March 11, 1734 |
| William Parsons (1701-1757) | March 11, 1734 – May 5, 1746 |
| Robert Greenway | May 5, 1746 – June 13, 1763 |
| John Edwards | July 11, 1763 – February 13, 1764 |
| Francis Hopkinson (1737-1791) | February 13, 1764 – May 13, 1765 |
| James Johnston | May 13, 1765 – May 9, 1768 |
| Ludowick Sprogell | May 9, 1768 – November 13, 1769 |
| John DeMauregnault | May 2, 1769 – August 5, 1771 |
| William Attmore | August 5, 1771 – May 10, 1773 |
| Charles Cist (1738-1805) | May 10, 1773 – March 7, 1774 |
| Francis Damon | April 14, 1774 – June 10, 1777 |
| Samuel Lobdell | June 27, 1777 – December 8, 1778 |
| John Todd, Sr. | December 8, 1778 – June 16, 1779 |
| Bernard Fearis | June 24, 1779 – January 11, 1780 |
| Joseph Fawcett | January 11, 1780 – January 13, 1784 |
| John Todd, Jr. | January 13, 1784 – February 3, 1785 |
| Zachariah Poulson (1761-1844) | February 8, 1785 – March 6, 1806 |
| George Campbell, Jr. (d. 1855) | April 10, 1806 – May 14, 1829 |
| John Jay Smith (1798-1881) | May 14, 1829 – February 6, 1851 |
| Lloyd Pearsall Smith (1822-1886) | February 6, 1851 – died July 2, 1886 |